Thursday, June 19, 2025

EATING THE FORBIDDEN FRUIT

 

EATING THE FORBIDDEN FRUIT 

Westminster Shorter Catechism 15

Quest. What was the sin whereby our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created?

Ans. The sin whereby our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created, was their eating of the forbidden fruit.

Introduction

Image from Web
Having already looked at the question: What is sin? And having seen that sin is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of, the law of God, it is with this definition of sin in mind that we are ready to consider Westminster Shorter Catechism 15. We need to keep before us the fact that sin is the breaking of God’s Law. For, in the following we’re going to be looking into how our first parents broke the Law, i.e., God’s Law.

Now, just before we get into the thick of it, we need to state what we mean by God’s Law. By the “Law of God” we mean God’s Law as summarized in the Ten Commandments. Never lose sight of the fact that the Ten Commandments are simply a summary of God’s Law. By definition, to give a summary is simply to give the substance of a thing. A summary is an abridgement, a condensation, and a shortened version of a thing. Therefore, the Ten Commandments are God’s Law in shorthand. So, each of the Ten Commandments is in a sense a “headline” with a more exhaustive story attached, which is to say that each of the Ten Commandments needs to be unpackaged.

Each commandment is a container in which God’s Law is enclosed. Or, to come at it from a different angle, each one of the Ten Commandments has a specific function while remaining inter-connected to the other nine, which is to say that God’s Law applies to every area of our lives. But each of the Ten Commandments addresses a specific area specifically. E.g., “You shall not murder” applies to the sphere of physical wellbeing. Yet you can see how this connects with the 4th Commandment in which God commands us to have one day every seven as rest in Him.

Man needs rest for his physical wellbeing. Or we can see how the commandment “You shall not steal” applies to private property. God has declared one day in seven as His Sabbath, i.e., day of rest. Therefore, we would, in a sense, be stealing from God if we did not obey His commandment to rest on the day He has provided. And if you work seven days a week for any length of time your own physical and spiritual wellbeing will begin to suffer.

Anyway, I don’t want us to get too bogged down in this at the moment. Suffice to say that all Ten Commandments are interconnected each one with the other. This is on account of the fact that the Decalogue is simply a summary of God’s Moral Law. Sin then, is the breaking of this Moral Law.

This is going to help us understand what we’re looking at in the following.

The Tree

We need to consider the tree that bore the forbidden fruit. The reason we need to do this is because a tree figures so prominently at the centre of our first parents’ sin. That tree is of course the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.

Now, there’s no question that the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was a special tree. The history of this tree is that it was created on the third day of creation week. “Then God said, ‘Let the earth bring forth grass, the herb that yields seed, and the fruit tree that yields fruit according to its kind, whose seed is in itself, on the earth’, and it was so” (Gen. 1:11). So, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was like every other tree in that it could reproduce itself. Part of its reproduction mechanism was its fruit, which could be easily consumed by human beings, even Adam and Eve. So far so good.

Now, in Genesis 2:8 we read, “The LORD God planted a garden eastward in Eden, and there He put the man whom He had formed.” So, possibly Adam got to watch the LORD God plant the Garden of Eden. The idea seems to be that the LORD collected trees, shrubs, plants and so forth from elsewhere, and made a special Garden – a place of special delight. In other words, the trees didn’t just spring up at God’s command as they did on the third day. Rather, they were transported and transplanted to a corner of Eden – as was Adam himself.

And then we read these words, “And out of the ground the LORD God made every tree grow that is pleasant to the sight and good for food. The tree of life was in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil” (Gen. 2:9). The word “Eden” comes from a word meaning “delight”, “pleasant” or “pleasure”. And we see that the trees of the Garden of Eden were pleasant to the eye. This includes, of course, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.

So, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil wasn’t a grotesque or ugly looking tree. In fact, we read in Genesis 3:6 that Eve found it “pleasant to the eyes.” Therefore, the tree itself was a “good” tree, not a bad tree or an evil tree. For at the end of the 6th day of creation didn’t God find everything He had made pleasant to His sight when He declared it all “very good”?

So, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil had been planted by the LORD in the midst of the Garden of Eden – along with, or beside, the tree of life. Therefore, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was a pleasant tree in a pleasant place. But what makes the tree of the knowledge of good and evil such a special tree? Did it have any special qualities inherent in it? Well, again it had an aesthetic beauty. It was pleasant to the sight. But we’ve also seen that it was good for food.

So, what kind of tree was it? An apple tree? We still talk about an Adam’s apple when we refer to a jutty-out bump in the throat of a man. I would imagine that this is alluding to Adam swallowing the forbidden fruit and its getting stuck in his throat. But, contrary to popular belief, the Bible doesn’t state that the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was an apple tree.

However, I should point out that the Bible does mention apple trees. E.g. metaphorically in Song of Solomon 2:3, “Like an apple tree among the trees of the woods, so is my beloved among the sons. I sat down in his shade with great delight, and his fruit was sweet to my taste.” You can just about see Adam and Eve in that verse. There they are sitting down in the shade of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil among the trees of the Garden. “So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree desirable to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate. She also gave to her husband with her, and he ate” (Gen. 3:6).

To be sure, the Shulamite in the Song of Solomon is talking about her beloved and not an actual apple tree or an actual apple. However, one might wonder if Solomon had the tree of the knowledge of good and evil in mind when he penned the Song of Solomon. But, even if he did, he would most likely have been referring to that other tree in the midst of the garden, i.e. the tree of life.

Image from Web
My wife loves peaches so much so that she reckons it must have been a peach tree. I usually remind her of the striking similarity (at least to me) between the French words for sin and peach – péché and pêche respectively.

Our first parents sinned by eating the forbidden fruit. But all of this is just fanciful, isn’t it? We don’t know what kind of tree the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was. All we know for sure is that it was a fruit tree that was delightful to the eye and good for food. So, other than that, there were no special qualities to this tree. Its fruit didn’t contain poison, per se, although the whole of humanity, including you and me, was ‘poisoned’ by the eating of it.

To eat of its fruit was sin. Why? Because God said so! Think about it, God had applied His Moral Law to a fruit tree. He had told Adam that it was His own personal private property. He, as it were, had said to Adam with regard to the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, “You shall not steal.” But steal Adam did and murdered himself and the whole of humanity with him in the process!

Our first parents coveted what was not theirs to have. They dishonoured God their Father. They were not pure and loyal. In other words, they did not love God and their neighbour (including you and me) as themselves. They proved this by eating the forbidden fruit.

The Treason

Treason is betrayal or breach of allegiance or of disobedience toward one’s sovereign or government. When our first parents started eating the forbidden fruit, they were breaking God’s Law, which is to say that they were breaching God’s covenant. As the prophet Hosea says, “Adam transgressed the covenant” (Hos. 6:7).

So we ask, what covenant? To which we answer, the Covenant of Works (as we call it). God had entered into this covenant-relationship or arrangement with Adam upon his creation. And He gave him the outward command not to eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. A covenant as you know, is a conditional promise. Adam was promised or threatened with death if he disobeyed God and ate the forbidden fruit. And conversely, he was promised life, everlasting life in the heavenly kingdom if he obeyed.

So, Adam exercised the free will he had before the Fall and committed treason by choosing death over life. The outward test of Adam’s covenant obedience was centred on the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. “And the LORD God commanded the man, saying, ‘Of Every tree in the garden you may freely eat; but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die’” (Gen. 2:16-17).

To paraphrase a little, “Adam, if you want to show your allegiance to the covenant, don’t eat the forbidden fruit. If you love Me keep My commandments. But if you ever want to break this agreement, just eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. But remember that by doing so you will forfeit eternal life and bliss and instead choose misery and death”.

Image from Web
So, our first parents sinned by eating the forbidden fruit. They broke the whole of God’s Law when they did so. For James says, “For whoever shall keep the whole law, and yet stumble in one point, he is guilty of all” (James 2:10). So, when Adam sinned, he was guilty of breaking the whole Law. Therefore, the breaking of the Covenant of Works is the same as breaking the whole Law.

So, what on earth was Adam up to? Well, in Genesis 3:5 the serpent says, “For God knows that in the day you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.” So, just as Satan wanted to be like God by exalting himself, so Adam also elevated himself above the Law of God.

But this is treason against the sovereign Lawgiver; the LORD God Himself! The sin was in the fact that God had commanded Adam not to eat the fruit. If God had not commanded or forbidden it, it wouldn’t be a sin, would it? Therefore, it is God alone who declares what is sin and what is not sin.

So, we see then that our first parents sinned by eating the forbidden fruit, not because of anything in the fruit or the tree itself, but rather because they disobeyed a direct command of God. God’s Word is Law and is therefore to be heeded and obeyed! So, our first parents rebelled against their Sovereign when they disobeyed Him. They also aspired to a higher state, namely, to be like God, i.e. as a Lawgiver. Our first parents wanted to set up their own kingdom in which they were the sovereign rulers, where they would make up their own rules about what is right and what is wrong, good and evil.

We see this kind of megalomaniacal desire acted out by the likes of Adolf Hitler. His desire, I believe, was simply an intense twisting and sinful warping of the Cultural Mandate to subdue the earth. But God alone created all things from nothing by His creative fiat. And fallen Man attempts to do likewise in various unlawful ways. E.g. he prints paper money without any real money, i.e. gold to back it. He refers to this paper money as if it were the real money itself!

What was the paper money issued by the Confederate States of America worth when their side lost the Civil War? It wasn’t worth the paper it was printed on because there was nothing to back it! Only God can create something from nothing. Man can’t. It’s all alchemy, isn’t it? At least in the Middle Ages fallen Man tried to make gold from lead. But nowadays they try to make gold out of paper. Alchemy gone awry! It is all part of, and a continuation of, our first parents treacherous and treasonous conspiring with God’s enemy the Devil against God. 

Image from Web
The Devil was there, wasn’t he? He’s usually depicted as coiled around the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. He is a constrictor. He put the squeeze on Adam and Eve to join him in rebellion against God. But he did so by painting God as a constrictor! “Has God indeed said, ‘You shall not eat of every tree in the garden’?” “What do you mean that you cannot eat of every tree? How narrow, how restrictive! Why don’t you just ignore God’s Law and become a law unto yourselves? Why don’t you forget about God’s Law and just write your own?” And isn’t this where we’re at today in the Western World, even the whole world today? We can be thankful that God’s Law was written into Western Constitutions such as ours (in Australia). But you can see that today we are becoming more and more law-makers and less and less law-appliers.

God’s Law is less and less being applied in the courts of law today. E.g. adultery and homosexuality used to be crimes. But this is no longer the case. Even lying is now being referred to as the less precise terms of ‘spin-doctoring, ‘gaslighting’. But not only did God sovereignly create the universe from nothing, but He also has sovereign providential control over all creatures and their actions.

Fallen Man seeks to be like God by passing laws left right and centre to govern every creature and its actions. If you don’t believe me, just look at tax-law and traffic and city parking laws as a couple of examples. Look at all the political correctness laws that are now cluttering up the law books! To be sure a lot of these laws are designed to help, but these laws are legion! And yet Mankind has the audacity to call the Ten Commandments too constricting!

But all of this just goes to prove that what the Apostle Paul says is true. “Therefore, just as through one man sin entered the world, and death through sin, and thus death spread to all men, because all sinned” (Rom. 5:12). All broke the Covenant of Works. All broke the eternal Moral Law. So, this means that when Adam sinned we all sinned. Or as the prophet Hosea says, “Like Adam they transgressed the covenant” (Hos. 6:7). Which covenant did Adam transgress? The Covenant of Works. Therefore, by our first parents eating the forbidden fruit, all humanity became covenant breakers, setting themselves up as the new lawmaker and giver.

In Romans 1:31 the Apostle Paul speaks of fallen man as “covenant breakers.” You’ll need to look in the King James Version to find those exact words. The New King James Version has the word “untrustworthy” instead of “covenant breakers.” The New International Version renders it “faithless”. But whether you use the words “untrustworthy”, “faithless”, “perfidious”, “treacherous” it all begs the question: with regard to what is fallen Man untrustworthy, faithless etc.? The general answer is of course “God”. But the Greek word used in Romans 1:31 speaks of a pact, an agreement – a covenant! The Greek word is best translated “covenant breakers” as in the King James Version. Therefore, fallen Man is untrustworthy, faithless with regard to God’s covenant.

“And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient; being filled with all unrighteousness, fornication, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness; full of envy, murder, debate, deceit, malignity; whisperers, backbiters, haters of God, despiteful, proud, boasters, inventors of evil things, disobedient to parents, without understanding, covenantbreakers, without natural affection, implacable, unmerciful: Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them” (Rom. 1:28-32 KJV).

To break that covenant was to break God’s eternal Moral Law.

Conclusion

If sin is the breaking of God’s Moral Law, and if all Mankind became covenant breakers on account of our first parents eating the forbidden fruit, then we have to conclude that eating the forbidden fruit involved much, much more than breaking one single command of God. We have to conclude that in Adam the entire human race broke the entire Moral Law when he ate of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, which is to say that Man’s treason infiltrates every sphere of life to which the Ten Commandments may be applied. Which is to say that Fallen Man is at war with God in regards other gods, graven images, taking the Lord’s name in vain, the Sabbath, honouring father and mother, murder, adultery, stealing, lying, and coveting – all Ten Commandments.

In a word, fallen Man is at war with the Moral character of God. For the Moral Law is the outward expression of the inward Moral character of God. The Moral Law is the revelation of who and what God is. Therefore, when our first parents sinned by eating the forbidden fruit, they didn’t just steal an apple and eat it – big deal! They actually rebelled against everything that makes God God! They broke God’s everlasting covenant that was being administered by God to Man at that time in the form of the Covenant of Works. So, we see then that our first parent did not like that covenant arrangement and declared their mind on this matter by eating the forbidden fruit. Therefore, an act of outright treason toward God took place right under the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.

But God is full of grace and mercy. The eating of the forbidden fruit wasn’t the end of Mankind. For, our first parents drew blood when they bit into that forbidden fruit, when they bit the hand that fed them. They drew the blood of God’s everlasting covenant. That blood – the blood of Christ’s cross – is the blood that washes away all our sin. Make sure that His shed blood has washed away your sins. Repent and believe in the gospel of Jesus Christ.

We’ve looked at the question: What was the sin whereby our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created? And we’ve considered something of the answer: The sin whereby our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created, was their eating of the forbidden fruit.

Tuesday, June 17, 2025

WHAT IS SIN?

 

WHAT IS SIN? 

Westminster Shorter Catechism 14

Quest. What is sin?

Ans. Sin is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of, the law of God. 

Introduction

For the Christian, are sin and crime two different things? If sin and crime are two different things, then what is the difference? When is a crime not a sin? Is speeding, e.g., a crime but not a sin? Of course, speeding is a sin as well as a crime. When you drive your car over the agreed safe speed limit you are endangering your own life and the lives of those around you. You’re supposed to be loving your neighbour as yourself, so speeding on public roads is unloving (unless you’re in an emergency vehicle or something like that).

Image from Web

But a crime is not always a sin, and a sin is not always a crime in our society, is it? For instance, it’s a sin to have sex outside of marriage, but nowadays adultery is not a crime. But if you looked in the Bible, would you be able to give a good argument why adultery should not be a crime? Let me zoom in a little more to what I’m driving at. What makes a sin a sin and what makes a crime a crime? Who decides what is a sin and what is not a sin?  And who decides what is a crime and what is not a crime? What is the determining factor?  Is it the State, i.e., the “Power Authority” who determines what is a crime? You hear of people committing “crimes against the State”, don’t you? And isn’t it the State that determines speed limits and the likes?

So, are you sinning against the State when you speed, seeing as in many instances speeding is sinning? Well, this is what the State believes, isn’t it? Otherwise, why would speeding fines go into the State coffers? But the State tends not to call any crime a “sin”. Why? Is it because the State doesn’t want to pass moral judgment on people? Well, what about the taxpayer funded advertisement campaign we had in Australia, I think it was by the Federal Government, that said: “If you drink and drive, you’re a [blank] idiot”? That’s a moral judgment, isn’t it? Drink drivers are idiots! 

So, why doesn’t the State call someone who has sex outside of marriage an [blank] idiot? Is it because no one’s life is in danger of being maimed or ended through illicit sex? Well, what about AIDS? That can end your life, yes? And what about all the other sexually transmitted diseases that can cause infertility, blindness, and what have you? What about the innocent lives that are ended through abortion on account of unwanted pregnancies sometimes on account of unlawful sexual relations?

Image from Web
So, from the Christian perspective a sin is a sin because God says so in His Word. And a crime is a crime because the State says so. Therefore, all sins are not necessarily crimes in the eyes of the State, just as all crimes are not necessarily sins in the eyes of God. As Christians we need to get a handle on the question: What is sin? Apart from helping us to see what God means by sin; it will also help us learn to discern the difference between what the State calls crime and what God calls sin. It will assist us in avoiding the danger of becoming either legalists or antinomians through following the philosophy of a secular or non-Christian (and sometimes blatantly anti-Christian) State and not the Word of God.

If the State, e.g., says sex outside of marriage is not a crime and we start teaching that, as if it were truth, then we’re guilty of teaching people to sin! Or, if we tell people that reckless speeding is not a sin, then we’re saying it’s all right to commit crime. And teaching people to sin is a sin in itself – for it’s a form of Antinomianism. And conversely, if we teach people, e.g., that making and drinking wine is a sin when it’s not, we are actually sinning against God – for this is a form of legalism. Therefore, both Antinomianism and Legalism are sin according to the Word of God. For Antinomianism permits what God forbids, and Legalism forbids what God permits.

So, we would do well to learn what the Bible says about sin if we are to keep a handle on things.

Sin Identified

There are two kinds of sins. To quote Roderick Lawson of Maybole, “The first consists in not doing what God commands; the second consists in doing what God forbids.” Then he gives an example by making the point, “Our first parents committed the latter.”[1] Which is to say that Adam and Eve sinned by doing what God had forbidden. They did what God had commanded Adam not to do; they ate the forbidden fruit. Rowland Ward, who has modernized the language of the Westminster Shorter Catechism, puts it like this, “Sin is any failure to measure up to what God requires, or any disobedience to His commands.”[2] I think this rendering helps us toward understanding what the Bible says about sin. For if you don’t measure up to what God requires, you are sinning. And if you don’t do what He says you are to do, you are sinning. So, we can see then that it is God, not the State, that sets the standard of perfect living. Therefore, we are to use the canon of Scripture alone to measure sin.

Now, God through His Apostle John provides us with a clear statement of what is sin. “Whoever commits sin also commits lawlessness, and sin is lawlessness” (in 1 John 3:4). So, sin then is lawlessness, or as the NIV puts it, “Sin is the transgression of the law.”

Now, what “law” do you think this refers to – Man’s Law or God’s Law? Or, as some would style it, ‘Criminal Law’ or ‘Moral Law’? Well again, a crime is only a crime when it is a transgression of God’s measure or standard. For in the Christian worldview a crime is only a crime when it violates God’s Moral Law. In other words, what we’re saying is that so called ‘Criminal Law’ must not be detached from God’s Moral Law, i.e., the Ten Commandments, because it is God’s Law that gives ‘Criminal’ or ‘Legal’ law its ultimate authority. Therefore ‘Criminal Law’ or ‘State Law’ must always be subject to God’s Moral Law. Or, if you will, the State itself must be subject to God, even in its laws.

The State should simply apply God’s Moral Law in all its dealings. But, as we all know, this is not the reality, even in Australia, even though it is a nation founded under God.[3] There are many laws that run contrary to God’s Moral Law appearing on its books. Abortion, homosexuality, cohabitation, prostitution, taking innocent people’s guns from them, squandering taxpayers’ money, and the list goes on.  But the point I make is that the State usurps the authority of God when it passes laws contrary to God’s Moral Law.

When the State sets itself up as the Lawgiver without reference to God and His Moral Law, it sets itself up as God. However, as God in the 1st Commandment says, “You shall have no other gods before Me.” So, we see then, that not only does God hold individuals accountable, He also holds whole nations accountable.

The Law is King, not the Church or the State. Both must subject themselves to His Moral Law or suffer the consequences. Why? Because “Whoever commits sin also commits lawlessness, and sin is lawlessness.” Whether it’s the State or the Church or the Family or the individual or the Nation – all sin is lawlessness. And this is exactly what we find in our world today. It’s as the Lord says, “The earth is also defiled under its inhabitants, because they have transgressed the laws, changed the ordinance, broken the everlasting covenant” (Isa. 24:5). When our first parents ate of the forbidden fruit the world became defiled. The world began inventing its own laws, laws contrary to God’s eternal Moral Law.

Now, I’m sure we’re all familiar with the verse which says, “All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (Rom. 3:23). In other words, we don’t measure up to God’s Moral standard. Therefore, we should expect the State and even the Church to get it wrong from time to time. Our own Confession states that “All synods or councils since the Apostle’s times, whether general or particular, may err, and many have erred; therefore they are not to be made the rule of faith or practice, but to be used as a help in both.”[4]

So, the Church herself errs from time to time and, as we’ve already noted, so does the State. But what constitutes an error? That which fails to measure up to what God requires and that which disobeys what He has commanded.

Sin Illustrated

Is Stem-cell Research one of those moral, ethical or legal “grey areas”? Yet some scientists and others think nothing of destroying fertilized human embryos. But even a quick glance at the Ten Commandments, particularly the 6th Commandment, would prove that it is a sin to intentionally destroy any human embryo. For, to discard impregnated human embryos is by definition a form of infanticide.

This is the stuff of Pharaoh killing infants when Moses was a baby, and King Herod killing infants when Jesus was a baby. It was, is, and always will be, a sin to unlawfully take the life of another human being. Therefore, it is unlawful or lawlessness to impregnate human embryos with the intention of destroying any one of them. Why? Because God in the 6th Commandment states, “You shall not murder.”

Let me illustrate this by asking you, for instance, if the man you read about in the Book of Acts 3 who was lame from birth is a human being. “And a certain man lame from his mother’s womb was carried, whom they laid daily at the gate of the temple” (Acts 3:2). So, here’s what I’m driving at: Was this man a fully formed, a fully developed, human being? No, his legs hadn’t fully formed or developed, so he had to be carried. But who on the planet earth, would say that this crippled man was not a human being? Let me rephrase that question: Who would claim he was not a human being? – (apart from Adolf Hitler who would have hated this crippled man because he was a Jew. Adolf Hitler justified his systematic extermination of the Jews by holding that Jews were not fully developed or fully evolved human beings – that they were sub-human).

Now, let’s turn back to human embryos. Many scientists claim that an impregnated human embryo does not a human make. Many abortionists claim a child before the second trimester in its mother’s womb does not a human make. This is how they justify their sin of murder! They claim that it’s not a fully formed or fully developed human being. Therefore, the State says it is permissible to destroy it – it’s not a crime! But what does God’s Law say? “You shall not murder.”

Is a fertilized embryo a human being? It might not be fully formed or fully developed, but is it a human being? Of course it is! David says under inspiration of the Holy Spirit, “Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity, and in sin my mother conceived me” (Psa. 51:5). Notice that it was David and not an embryo who was conceived. For he says, “in sin my mother conceived me.” If anyone had destroyed that embryo, who would they have terminated? King David!

David says, “You [i.e., God] have formed my inward parts; You have woven me in my mother’s womb. I will praise You, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made” (Psa. 139:13). Then he says something very remarkable and applicable to today. “Your eyes saw my substance, being yet unformed.” Or as the NIV puts it: “Your eyes saw my unformed body.” Now, what’s the difference between David’s unformed body and the lame man’s unformed body in Acts 3? The man in Acts 3 was lame from birth. His legs were what we call de-formed because they hadn’t fully formed in his mother’s womb. But it would most certainly be murder if someone took his life just because he was not a fully developed human being! And yet sadly some women seek to abort their children for minor things such as a cleft pallet and worse, and the State in many cases obliges! But sin is ANY want of conformity unto, or transgression of, the law of God. If people think that IVF and Stem-cell research is a grey area, then surely those people would be wise to err on the side of caution rather than be party to the murder innocent human beings.

Let’s now consider a few examples of failing to conform to God’s Law. Then we’ll consider a few examples of doing what His Law forbids. In Luke 10 we read the familiar Parable of the God Samaritan. Jesus said that Parable to answer a question He was asked about God’s Law. As you know, the sum of the God’s Moral Law (of which the Ten Commandments are themselves a summary), is: “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your strength, and with all your mind, and your neighbour as yourself” (Luke 10:27). In response to this someone asked Jesus, “And who is my neighbour?” Hence the Parable of the Good Samaritan. It was to answer a question about God’s Law.

We know the story of the man who was left lying by the side of the road like a pound of raw mince after being beaten up by a bunch of thieves. Jesus, in this Parable illustrates the two kinds of sins, which are not doing what God commands, and doing what God forbids.

Image from Web
God has commanded you to love your neighbour as yourself. The priest and the Levite in the Parable illustrate the not doing what God commands. We see this in their inaction toward a helpless human being in need. “Now by chance a certain priest came down that road. And when he saw him, he passed on the other side. But a certain Levite, when he arrived at the place, came and looked, and passed on the other side” (Luke 10:31-32).

So, we can see that they were sinning. Sin is lawlessness. They did not do what they ought to have done. They ought to have kept God’s Moral Law and helped the helpless man when they had opportunity. They ought to have done what God commands, i.e., love your neighbour as yourself. Would any of us like to be robbed, beaten up, left for dead, and while you’re lying there dying, have men walk past and not lift a hand to help?

Also, we see illustrated in this parable men doing what God forbids. It was thieves who relieved this helpless man of his clothing. God in the 8th Commandment says, “You shall not steal” (Exod. 20:15). They also wounded him to the point of death in the process. God in the 6th Commandment says, “You shall not murder” (Exod. 20:13).

It’s not hard to see how well this parable applies to the IVF, Stem cell, abortion issue today. Helpless, innocent human beings are being wounded and murdered daily while people like the priest and Levite just walk past not lifting a hand to help. It is as much a sin, a breaking of God’s Moral Law, to do nothing than it is to destroy innocent human life.

We’re all probably feeling suitably guilty at this point. We are fallen creatures living in a fallen world. And it wouldn’t be hard to heap up examples of where we all fail miserably to keep God’s Moral Law. We ought to be thankful that God has sent us a Saviour in Jesus Christ. He is the Saviour of sinners like us. Let’s all trust in Him for our salvation and not our feeble attempts to keep His Law.

But, by way of example of how we ought to keep God’s Law in society, Jesus introduces the Good Samaritan into the story. The Samaritan bends over backwards helping this poor helpless human being. You know the story; he truly loved his neighbour as himself. He esteemed the wounded traveller better than himself (Phil. 2:3-4). Instead of the Parable of the Good Samaritan it should be called the Parable of the Good Neighbour. He took care of all the wounded man’s needs. He was the Good Neighbour, which is to say that he kept God’s Law by doing what it commands and not doing what it forbids.

Conclusion

It would certainly make for a better and more peaceable society if people would learn to behave like the Good Samaritan. One of the beauties of living in a democratic society as opposed to a dictatorship for example, is that we are given opportunity to tell our politicians what we think of abortion and other such issues, which is to say that we get to tell them how society ought to behave! And as the Apostle Paul says to Timothy, we are to pray “…for all who are in authority, that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and reverence…” (1 Tim. 2:2).

Christians, the Lord’s Church on earth, is the Light of the World and the Salt of the Earth. Therefore, if we would be light and salt we need to learn and keep God’s Law. We need to be like the Good Samaritan. We need to show forth God’s Law by our actions. But we feel inadequate, don’t we? When we look at God’s Law, we see our own sin! We see clearly that none of us measure up. And we see that we at times disobey God’s commands. But remember what the Apostle John says, “And if anyone sins, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the Righteous” (1 John 2).

Make sure then, that Jesus Christ is your Advocate. Otherwise, you yourself will need to pay the penalty you owe God for your sins. The State might slap you on the wrist, fine you, or throw you in prison, depending on the seriousness of your crime against it. But Almighty God sees even the least little one of your sins against Him as serious enough to throw you into Hell forever! He sees your sins against Him as serious enough that He sent His only begotten Son that whoever believes in Him may not perish but have everlasting life.

We’ve looked at the question What is sin? And we’ve seen that sin is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of, the law of God.



[1] Roderick Lawson, The Shorter Catechism with Commentary and Scripture Proofs, (Free Church of Scotland Publications Committee, no date), Edinburgh, 14.

[2] Rowland. S. Ward, Learning the Christian Faith – The Shorter Catechism for Today – with Modernised Text and Explanatory Notes, (New Melbourne Press, Wantirna, Australia, 1998), 10.

[3] The preamble to the Constitution of Australia states: “Whereas the people of New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia, Queensland, and Tasmania, humbly relying on the blessing of Almighty God, have agreed to unite in one indissoluble Federal Commonwealth under the Crown of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and under the Constitution hereby established.”

[4] Westminster Confession of Faith, Chapter 31, paragraph 4.

Monday, June 16, 2025

HOW MAN SINNED

 

HOW MAN SINNED 

Westminster Shorter Catechism 13

Quest. Did our first parents continue in the estate wherein they were created?

Ans. Our first parents, being left to the freedom of their own will, fell from the estate wherein they were created, by sinning against God.

Introduction

In the following we’re going to be talking about one of the biggest mysteries in the universe. What we’ll be looking at is a bigger mystery than the building of the pyramids. It’s a bigger mystery than the building of Stonehenge. What we’re looking at is: How man sinned. Notice that we’re not asking why man sinned, though we’ll need to touch on this. But we’re asking the question How?

Free Will

Image from Web
Our first parents, Adam and Eve, were created perfect. Part of that perfection was that they both had free will, which is to say that before the Fall the wills of our first parents were free from bondage.

Now, we need to be really careful to define our terms when we talk about “free will.” First, we need to try to define what we mean by man’s “will.” Then we’ll talk about “free” will. Right then, we human beings operate according to our will. Our will is the faculty we use to make decisions. If you will, our will is our “choosery.” And we always choose according to our will. Therefore, our will is that faculty we use to determine or choose the course of action we will take in any given situation.

Think about it, a human being never acts against his own will. We might act against our “better judgment” as we say. But we will never ever go against our own will. If someone tries to force us to go against our own will we will resist. Why? Well, it’s because we only ever operate in accordance with our own will. We most certainly don’t like being forced to do things against our will. For instance, a criminal may be arrested by the police against his own will. Therefore, he will not want to get into the back of the police car, but he must, or else! But even though he might comply, he is being held against his will. He wants to or wills to remain free from the police. Or like the little boy whose teacher told him to sit down in class or else! The little boy said to his classmates, “On the outside it might look like I’m sitting, but on the inside I’m still standing!” He hasn’t acted against his will. He has simply chosen to sit down in accordance with his will.

Whether someone physically forces you, or whether they verbally threaten you, you are still freely exercising your own will when you comply. But (and here’s the point) you always will and only ever choose to obey or disobey that which is in accordance to your will. If you do not will it, you will not choose it. If you do not want it, you will not pick it. Your will then, is your “choosery.” And your actions are always in line with your “choosery.”

Right, what would happen then, if there were something wrong with your “choosery”? What would happen if your “choosery” were affected by sin, or as we say, in bondage to sin? All your decisions would be affected, wouldn’t they? It would mean that you would have a bias toward sin, wouldn’t it? It would mean that you would be inclined towards disobeying God, for that’s what sin is. Therefore, it would mean that you would have a tendency toward bad and not good.

Now, in saying this we’re not suggesting that everyone with a bias toward sin is as bad as they can possibly be. To be sure a thief is not as bad as a murderer. Nor is one who covets as bad as a thief. But nevertheless, ALL who do these things are bad, sinful! This is the way things were with mankind after the Fall. Genesis 6:5 sums up our condition after the Fall, “Then the LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.”

Those of you who are familiar with the TULIP acronym will understand this verse in terms the “T” which stands for “Total Depravity.” To have every intent of the thoughts of your heart only evil continually is to be depraved in your total being. It doesn’t mean that you are as bad as you can possibly be. But it does mean that your will decides only for that which is bad or evil in spiritual terms, which means that your “choosery” isn’t functioning the way it was designed.

And just in case you think that this verse, Genesis 6:5 (just quoted), applies only to the time before the flood, let me remind that Paul says the same thing in the New Testament. In Romans 3 he says that Jews and Greeks or Gentiles are all under sin. And, quoting from the Psalms he says, “As it is written: ‘There is none righteous, no, not one; there is none who understands; there is none who seeks after God. They have all gone out of the way; they have together become unprofitable; there is none who does good, no, not one’” (Rom. 3:10-12).

Image from Web
So, under inspiration of the Holy Spirit, Paul, the Lord’s Apostle, declares that there is none who does good, no, not one. What does he mean by “good”? Well, he can’t mean there is none who helps old women across the street, for there are! He can’t mean that there is none who gives money to charity, for there are! He can’t be talking about those things that we call good. So, what is he talking about? Well, that’s the very question WSC 13 is asking. Did our first parents continue in the estate wherein they were created?

How were Adam and Eve created? In what condition were they? Were they created in the estate or condition of neutrality as alleged by those who follow the teachings of Jacob Arminius? Are the Arminians correct when they teach that Adam was a neutral party in the Covenant of Works that God entered into with him before the Fall? It’s important that you consider this question, as it impacts on your view of the Fall, which in turn influences your view of the Gospel. If Adam’s will was neutral, then he did not Fall from a position of good but merely fell from a position of neutrality.

Do you see what I mean? It’s absurd to suggest that Adam and Eve were neutral in the pre-Fall Covenant of Works. Why? Because to claim neutrality is to claim disengagement! If you claim that Adam is neutral, i.e., unbiased toward good before the Fall, then you are saying that man took no part in the Covenant of Works!

When you put your car into neutral what happens?  Does the gear engage to drive you forward or in reverse? The car doesn’t want to drive you anywhere, does it? And because it’s in neutral it just idles, it cannot do anything – it cannot move! So how can anyone suggest that God left Adam’s will in “neutral” before the Fall? For this would mean that God never actually engaged Adam. It would mean that Adam just sat in neutral, idling! But was this the way God created our first parents? Didn’t God put them in gear, in D for drive, by blessing them and saying to them, “Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the earth”? (Gen. 1:28).

If God created Adam neutral, then why did He place him in the Garden and engage him to tend and keep it? Adam was created to work in the Garden, and not to be idle (Gen. 2:15). And more than this, how is it possible to enter into a covenant (as the LORD did with Adam) if one of the parties is neutral?

Did the LORD impose His covenant on Adam against Adam’s will? Or did Adam freely and willingly enter into the covenant with God? And why wouldn’t Adam freely and willingly enter into a covenant with God? Well, the only two reasons would be that he was either against God or that he was neither for nor against God, i.e., neutral.

Image from Web
So, in what estate then, in what condition, in what “gear” were our first parents when they were created? Were they created bad, in R for reverse, or were they created in N for neutral? or were they created good, in D for drive? The answer to this is found in Genesis 1:31a, “Then God saw everything that He had made; and indeed it was very good.”

Were our first parents’ part of everything God had made? Were their wills part of everything God had made? Yes? Well, this means that Adam was a man of “good will” – good will toward God and his wife Eve. In other words, he had a disposition toward loving God and his neighbour (even Eve) as himself. Therefore, what we’re saying then is that God did not leave Adam’s gearstick in neutral when He created him. Rather, the gearstick was in “G” for “good.”

So, it was from the estate of goodness our first parents fell, and not the estate of neutrality. This makes the sin of our first parents much more heinous than that advocated by those who teach neutrality. This makes our sin all the more repulsive. For this means that fallen man is actively engaging his will to reverse himself away from God. For if man only goes according to his will and his will is no longer a good will, then there truly is none who does good, no, not one as the Psalmist and the Apostle say. For how can anyone do the good the Apostle speaks of, unless he goes against his own will?

If the gearstick of your will is jammed in “B” for Bad, then how can you will yourself to put it into “G” for good? You can’t, because you won’t go against your own will! So, when we talk about free will we’re talking about what our first parents and all mankind lost when they rebelled against God.

Before the Fall they were able to do good (or bad if they chose). But after the Fall, they and us with them, as the Scriptures say, are able to do only (spiritual) bad, evil. This is what we mean when we speak of the bondage of the will as opposed to free will. However, we should note that fallen man is always free to exercise his own will. But since his will is bad and not good, he will – if left to his own devices – choose bad over spiritual good every time. He is free to choose good if he wants, but he won’t because he doesn’t want to. He doesn’t want to because his will is bad – it is in bondage. A bad “choosery” = bad choices every time.

There’s a lot more we could say on the subject of Free Will. However, our purpose here is to look at the fall of our first parents from the estate wherein they were created. So, having somewhat looked at the subject of the will, even free will, let’s now consider what happened to the free will our parents had when they were created.

Free Fall

We won’t spend too much time on this as we will be covering this subject in more depth in its place as we continue through the Westminster Shorter Catechism. But when we talk about the Fall of man we are talking about a great mystery.

Image from Web
When the Devil tempts you and me to sin, he does so by simply appealing to our sinful nature. It’s like being offered a million dollars to do some dastardly deed. We might begin to picture ourselves on a luxury yacht or in a mansion with a Rolls Royce parked in the driveway. Mind you, you’d need more than a million for these kinds of things, but you know what I mean. We are tempted to sin because of the selfish pleasure or gain it might bring us.

Even as Christians, we have a malfunctioning “choosery” which means we struggle somewhat deciding on the right moral course of action on account of a residue of sin remaining in us. Some things are obvious to us. Other things are not so obvious. We talk about grey areas of morality, moral dilemmas. We don’t always know right from wrong in black and white terms. But our first parents didn’t have our problem when they were created. Their “chooseries” were in perfect working order, which is to say that their wills were free from all malfunctioning, free from bondage. There was no computer virus in their system of thinking. There was no loose little Pac-man eating away at their decision-making abilities.

So, what caused our first parents to sin? Well, Adam tried to blame his wife (and God), and Eve tried to blame the Devil – as we see in Genesis 3. But, as you know, the LORD God didn’t accept their feeble excuses. Instead, He held each morally responsible for his own and her own moral actions. In other words, the LORD God declared each one guilty of mutiny and rebellion against His authority.

Why did our first parents exercise their free will and break God’s covenant with them and instead covenant with Death and the Devil? Well, that’s the mystery that God hasn’t been pleased to reveal to us. There was no sin in the hearts of our parents before the Fall. Therefore, Satan couldn’t appeal to their sinful nature as he can to us. But Fall they did as Adam broke the covenant God had made with him. And, since he was representing all mankind, all mankind has broken the Covenant of Works. And, in this, Adam placed the collective will of man, and the wills of every human being apart from Jesus, into bondage to sin and Satan.

Let’s consider Genesis 3:9-12 as a Scriptural example of the Fall of man. The LORD God there asks Adam three questions after the Fall. First question, Where are you?” To which Adam replied, “I heard Your voice in the garden, and I was afraid because I was naked; and I hid myself.” Second question, “Who told you that you were naked?” Third question, “Have you eaten from the tree which I commanded you that you should not eat?”

Let’s take the 3rd question first. God knew that Adam had eaten the forbidden fruit. So, why did He have to ask Adam? Well, it was most likely to give Adam opportunity to explain his actions. But not only that, the question was to remind Adam of his covenant with God. And God was reminding Adam of the specific verbal commandment or outward test He had given Adam. This refers back to Genesis 2:16-17, “Of every tree of the garden you may freely eat; but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die.”

Man, as you know, was made in the image and likeness of God, an aspect of which was that he had God’s Moral Law written on his heart in positive terms. Which is to say, as we’ve already noted, that Adam was created very good, which means also morally very good, along with all creation as it says in Genesis 1:31. And if he was morally very good then even his will was morally very good. So, we might say then that Adam was a man of good will. But was Adam showing good will toward God by disobeying His Moral Law and by eating the forbidden fruit when God had commanded him not to?

So, Adam exercised his free will and consciously chose to disobey the God who had made him. Whatever sinful thoughts Adam was having before he bit into that fruit we can only guess. But what we are told is that Adam broke the covenant, not by physically murdering his wife and children, but by eating the forbidden fruit. So, he exercised his free will and began his free fall into the estate of sin and misery by eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.

So, we know HOW man fell. He fell by disobeying God by eating the forbidden fruit. But the mystery remains – WHY? What compelled the good-willed Adam to disobey God? We don’t know. But we can see by the answer he gave God that he really meant to disobey God. “The woman whom You gave to be with me, she gave me of the tree and I ate” (Gen. 3:12). So we see that Adam is not only blaming Eve, but also God. “The woman whom You gave to be with me.”

Do you see what’s happening? Adam is blaming God for ultimately making him sin. “If You hadn’t given me that woman in the first place, then I wouldn’t be in this pickle!” So, is Adam right in his assessment? Did God make him sin? Or did Adam freely fall of his own free will? Let’s rephrase the question: Did Adam sin against God or did God sin against Adam?

Image from eweb
What was the 2nd question again that God asked Adam? “Who told you that you were naked?” Herein I believe we see proof that Adam sinned against God and not God against Adam. Adam had been created very good by God, which, among other things, means that Adam loved God and his neighbour (Eve and his future offspring) as himself. But now he is concerned only with his own nakedness. Immediately after the Fall he is concerned only with himself. Among other things he is trying to hide from God the embarrassment of his nakedness, by hiding in the bushes. It’s as if he’s been caught skinny dipping or something! “Who told you that it is wrong to skinny dip in public?” “I just know – instinctively, I guess!”

So, we see by Adam’s answer then, that he knows that he has broken God’s covenant. Before the Fall he was not ashamed of being naked (Gen. 2:25). But after the Fall he is ashamed, which is to say that Adam is experiencing a feeling of guilt. The question is, What is making him ashamed? What is making him feel guilty? Why would Adam be feeling guilty if it were God who had sinned against him by giving him the woman as Adam was alleging?

And then when we consider the 1st question God put to Adam, we can see that Adam’s fall was indeed a free fall. “Where are you?” Why wasn’t Adam looking for God to try to find out why God had caused him to break the covenant if he really was as innocent as he was alleging? What else are we to conclude other than that Adam had exercised his free will and in so doing began to free-fall from grace? Therefore, to state the obvious, God did not cause Adam to sin. Rather, Adam sinned of his own free will.

Before we wind up our present discussion, there’s one more thing we should note. Adam now had a guilty conscience to contend with. Unlike before the Fall, he now had an accusing conscience. “Adam, you’re naked!” His own guilty conscience was telling him he was naked. Why didn’t his conscience tell him that before? Well, it’s because his will was free before the Fall. His will was free because he had never gone against his conscience.

Up until the Fall he had always done that which was good. But he damaged his will when he somehow went against what he knew to be good. For some reason he had turned on himself – that’s the mystery. Somehow Adam acted against his own will – his own good will. He went against his own conscience. He as it were cut off his own nose to spite his face. He stabbed himself in the back! He took offence at being created in the image and likeness of God. He didn’t like what he saw in the mirror, so he tried to cover himself up with a fig leaf! Whatever way you look at it, his will was no longer free, but rather it was in some kind of self-centred bondage.

Man in Adam no longer had good will toward God and men. Rather he bore ill will toward God, even blaming Him for his own fallen condition. Is this not what you see around you today? Man bears ill will toward God by either trying to ignore Him or blame Him for the state of sin and misery in the world today. Therefore, man to this very day is still sinning against God, like our first parents so long ago. Like Adam they transgressed the covenant (Hos. 6:7).

Conclusion

Our will is in bondage until it is set free by the grace of God through His Son Jesus Christ. Therefore, Jesus Christ is the only One who can set us free from our bondage to sin. Only the blood that Jesus Christ shed on the cross can wash away our sins. He took the penalty owed to God’s justice for those who believe in Him for salvation. If by God’s grace you are trusting in Him to save you, then you are free indeed!

We’ve been looking at Westminster Shorter Catechism 13: Did our first parents continue in the estate wherein they were created? And we’ve seen something of the fact that Our first parents, being left to the freedom of their own will, fell from the estate wherein they were created, by sinning against God.